UPDATE 5/25:SSAG priced at $11, discounting their offering price 21% from midrange of the previous $13-$15. They reduced shares offered in the ipo from 14.3 million to 9 million. Also they've wiped out a 100 million dividend payout from offering to insiders....I think the deal now becomes something you can look at a bit closer. I still don't like that they've been unable to expand operating profit while rolling-up companies, but this slashing of price/restructuring of the deal probably means pricing level holds short term---if they'd gone ahead and shoved this offering in at $13 with the previous terms, it would have opened broken. It now goes from a shaky deal to one that the price is probably about right on offering. I don't think that it offers a compelling 'buy' still, but the deal will get done now and it should do okay shorter term.
Original analysis follows:
Roll-up global enterprise software/related services provider. 14.3 million share offering, 71 million outstanding. JP Morgan/Citigroup lead, price range $13-$15. Main focus is 'resource planning' essentially software suite/packages that manage a company's backbone from HR/thru sales & marketing/budgeting/supply chain etc...
Offering $$ is going to pay off insiders..where have we heard this before?
We've seen a plethora(of pinatas?) of LBO offerings in '05, we really haven't seen many roll-up offerings however. the 2005 version of SSAG is comprised essentially of four companies melded together over the past 5 years: Systems Software(whose assets were in bankruptcy, Infinium Software, Baan UK ltd., and EXE Technologies. There have been 4 or so other smaller deals, but these 4 represent the bulk of SSAG's revenue.
Offices all over the world, plenty of customers in a myriad of businesses, 70 patents etc...here worldwide really means worldwide, not like those airports that call themselves 'International' and have one flight to Toronto---you know who you are MDT.
To be honest I tend to step aside on most of these roll-up type ipo's---why? Well they often tend to be a bit bloated and one thing I'm looking for(one of the main things) is a lean company that will be able to flow future revenue growth right to the bottom line---roll-ups tend to have trouble with this all things being equal.
Industry is projected to grow revenue annually by 8-9% over next 3 years....however one thing we learned from the last economic slowdown is that new enterprise software purchases/licenses are one of the first expenditures to be reigned in during the tough times, so take those growth projections with that in mind.
Okay on to SSAG: Spread nicely all over the world, diverse product base, receives roughly 50% of revenue from servicing licensees; growth strategy appears to be to continue doing what they're doing.
Organic growth: looks like licensing fees grew about 20% organically thru 9 months ending 4/05(after a stagnant '04 though), but revenue itself grew organically only roughly 5% thru that time period. Including acquisitions revenue for that 9 month period grew roughly 12%.
sales/marketing jumped 17% for 6 months ending 1/1/05 while overall organic revenue grew just 6% thru that 6 month period. sales/marketing growing slower than licensing revenue so not disastrous, but I'm wondering why, with the nice recent licensing growth, the service/other revenue growth really not there past 6 months. They do note that support renewals have grown significantly in the past year, while reason for service revenue decline is a pullback on consulting concentration...really hard to get a handle on their numbers/growth as different segments have gone up/down as a % with each new acquisition.
debt to equity after offering manageable at about .16, so expect plenty more acquisitions to come.
Trailing earnings tough to get a clear picture due to the '04 acquisitions, but looks like roughly 30-35 X's earnings for 2004. Looks like they could potentially put 45-50 cents on the bottom line in '05 putting them roughly 28-30 X's earnings for '05 at mid-range of offering...actually a bit pricier than SAP/ORCL using just that measure.
I believe they'll continue to show nice top-line growth due to acquisitions but I'm not certain how well they'll be able to flow that to bottom line...They've done a nice job keeping overall expenses in line and more or less maintaining margins, so the companies have been integrated fairly well from that point of view. However the bottom line growth pales in comparison to the topline acquired revenue growth: their operating income has been comparitively flat since mid '02 even while doubling+ revenue
For every positive here to recommend this deal there seems to be a corresponding question mark...this isn't a bad deal, just one to me with some very real issues, the biggest being that organic revenue growth for the 9 months ending 4/05 trails the industry growth for that period--I don't like that in a new offering at all....what I'd like to see in a company like this is organic growth exceeding industry growth AND acquiring immediately bottom line accretive businesses. Yes that's a high bar, but it's what I want to see in this type of biz/company before I get interested....they don't seem to be really be doing either. the acquisitions seemed well managed and some have seemed to be accretive to earnings immediately while others seem to be more in the 'longer term investment' category.
I don't see really why one would want to own SSAG in the $13-$15 price range rather than say SAP or ORCL, two competitors...not a bad company or offering, just not real enticing in the $13-15 range to this analyst/trader.
Should be interesting to see if institutions want to take blocks of this one in range...I think it may be a tough sell, but a lot of '05 pricings have surprised me. I'll update should they slash this to $10-$11, that would be the price range to get me to take a 2nd closer look here. My guess is that with software finally catching a bid here recently, the window to get this out might be open. We'll see, I'm going to pass in the $13-$15 range, not with the disdain of many recent deals, but politely..pass nonetheless here.
Recent Comments